HomeStars is one of Canada's largest home-services review sites; its Best of award goes each year to the pros with the highest verified customer ratings.
View award source (opens in new tab)Public evidence profile · Checked May 2026
City Roofing & Aluminum Co.
Awards & recognition
2 independent awards
Trust Score
73out of 100
- Rated 4.9 from 155 reviews
Newest review December 2024
How this score is worked out
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume155
Independent sources1 independent public source
CredentialsNo credentials shown yet
How this score is made up
What customers say45 of 64.1
Independent checks21.9 of 21.9
Track record6.3 of 14.1
See the independent checks
- Ways to reach them12.5 of 12.5
- Photos of their work6.3 of 6.3
- Industry recognition3.1 of 3.1
Missing evidence lowers the score because we can't check it. It doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Claiming a profile never changes the score. Evidence context, not a guarantee of workmanship.
From customer reviews
What customers consistently say
What this contractor's customers report about their jobs, in their own words.
Stands behind their work: “Peter is very friendly, informative, and also provided follow up inspection after the repairs.” · HomeStars, Dec 12, 2024
Respectful and tidy in your home: “I was impressed by their thorough cleanup after work.” · HomeStars, Dec 12, 2024
Independent recognition
Awards & recognition
HomeStars is one of Canada's largest home-services review sites; its Best of award goes each year to the pros with the highest verified customer ratings.
View award source (opens in new tab)These are independent third-party awards: recognition earned from review communities and trade bodies, never paid placement.
Reviews · public evidence
What customers say
These reviews are published independently on the named public source below, not testimonials this business chose to show. We bring them together and link each one back to where it appeared, so you can open the source and read it yourself.
4.9out of 5
Customers often mention
Where these reviews are published
- HomeStars155 reviews · 4.9 avg
Detailed reviews
These are the individual reviews we hold for City Roofing & Aluminum Co., including the highlights above. The 155 headline total is the review volume reported across public review sources.
Extremely impressed with Peter for my roof replacement several years ago. Called him to check my roof after the wind storm recently and he showed up right away.
City Roofing replaced the roof of our previous home and fixed the roof leakage in our new home. They are professional and efficient, and I was impressed by their thorough cleanup after work. Peter is very friendly, informative, and also provided follow up inspection after the repairs. I would highly recommend their service!
The job was done flawlessly in two days. Clean up afterward was done properly. I had been using him for all roof related matters over the last 10 years, and have been very satisfied. Super reliable and trustworthy.
Peter from City Roofing did an exceptional job on my roof two years ago. He replaced shingles, installed tower vents, and set up de-icing cables. The quality of his work was outstanding, and his professionalism left me completely satisfied. What truly sets Peter apart is his remarkable after-sales service. Every year, he returns to clean the eavestroughs before winter snows at no additional cost. Last year, raccoons had messed up the de-icing cables and this year they left feces! Peter not only cleaned everything thoroughly but also fixed the cables, again free of charge! His dedication, attention to detail, and generosity are truly rare. I highly recommend Peter and City Roofing to anyone looking for top-quality roofing services and unparalleled customer care.
My first roof replacement was approximately 15 years ago with absoluty no issues with workmanship & materials. Two years ago when ineeded eavestrough called Peter who provided advise on improvements and avery competitive price.Both roofing and eavestrough jobs were done on time and finished well within the promised time. Had one issue with one of my downspout called Peter who without hesitation came to inspect the issue which was caused by leaves. Not a issue with workmanship or materials. Peter covered this under warranty A1 SERVICE . I found Peter to be knwleledgeable,professionable,honest and apleasure to deal with.
Local context
Rated 4.9, in line with the local average for plumbers in Scarborough
Across 49 plumbers in Scarborough, the typical rating is 4.9 out of 5. We compare against the same businesses a homeowner would find searching for this trade locally.
Sources
1 named public sourceWhere this information comes from
Everything on this page is drawn from named public sources. Where a source provides a public link, you can open the original and dig deeper.
Review sources
Public evidence last checked May 2026
About
City roofing and aluminum co. has been in business since 1994, over all these years, our extreme commitment to excellence and customer service make us one of the most trusted name in the roofing industry. Our roofing department offers residential and commercial services including re-roofing; new roof construction and retro-fitting, we install a wide range of materials such as asphalt shingles, metal roofing, composite roof and cedar wood shakes. Our aluminum department offers complete aluminum product.s and sheet metal work, our crews utilizes state of art tools and equipment to install aluminum soffit, fascia, seamless eavestrough and rainware accessories. What’s more, in addition to providing re-roofing services and new construction work, we also offer roofing repair services, on-going maintenance service, and roofing inspection consultations. These services are designed to extend the life of your roof by identifying and fixing the minor problems before they become major issues.
What this business says about itself
From their own website
What this business says about itself
- Emergency availability: Emergency Repair
These are statements the business makes on its own website, worth confirming in writing (and on the official registers) before you hire, not independently verified by us.
Independent checks
About this business
How long they've really been tradingThey state they've been established since 1994, but the earliest independent source we can find is 2025. Worth asking them about the gap.
They say, established1994Website online since2009Award-winning since2025
Your own checks
What to check before you hire
Worth checking yourself
Their public evidence comes from a single source. Look them up on another site before deciding.
No credentials are shown here and the business has not claimed this profile. Ask to see certificates and insurance directly.
Agree the call-out fee, the hourly or fixed rate, and whether parts are charged on top, in writing, before an emergency plumber starts. Out-of-hours overcharging and 'while I'm here' add-ons are common complaints.
Be wary of a plumber who, on a first visit, says your whole system or boiler must be replaced. Get a second opinion and an itemized quote (parts and labour separately) before agreeing to major work.
Gas work is licensed separately from general plumbing in every province. Make sure anyone working on a gas appliance or gas line holds the gas certification your province requires, and ask for proof of that certification before they start.
Want an extra legitimacy check? Run the Rogue Contractor Check on City Roofing & Aluminum Co. before you contact them.
Run Rogue Contractor Check →Good to know
Common questions about City Roofing & Aluminum Co.
Is City Roofing & Aluminum Co. available for emergencies?
They advertise Emergency Repair availability on their own website. This is the business's own statement on their website, not something we have independently checked. For an urgent job, call to confirm they can attend before you rely on it.
Is City Roofing & Aluminum Co. a legitimate business?
City Roofing & Aluminum Co. has 155 independent public reviews, rated 4.9 out of 5. This is independent public evidence gathered from named public sources (no ads, no paid placement), not a guarantee of workmanship. If anything here is out of date, the business can request a correction.
What do customers say about City Roofing & Aluminum Co.?
City Roofing & Aluminum Co. has 155 public reviews, averaging 4.9 out of 5. You can read the individual reviews and where each came from in the reviews section above.
How do I know City Roofing & Aluminum Co.'s reviews are genuine?
City Roofing & Aluminum Co.'s 155 public reviews come from a named public review source, and MyTrustedTraders links every one back to where it was published, so you can open the source and read them yourself rather than trusting a single curated page. MyTrustedTraders brings this public evidence together with no ads and no paid placement: we show where every review came from rather than selling rankings, so you can weigh the evidence for yourself.
Has City Roofing & Aluminum Co. won any awards?
City Roofing & Aluminum Co. holds 2 independent awards, including Best of HomeStars winner (2025); HomeStars Best of the Best winner (2025). These are third-party awards: recognition that has to be won, not self-issued.
Alba Tech Roofing
47Trust ScoreBuilding a public recordout of 100
47 reviews · Reviewed 10 months ago
Impressed Roofing Inc.
46Trust ScoreBuilding a public recordout of 100
13 reviewsFree quotes
Known for: Punctual
GTA Siding & Contracting
45Trust ScoreBuilding a public recordout of 100
28 reviews (5 in the last 12 months)
A-Pro Plumbing and Drain inc
35Trust ScoreBuilding a public recordout of 100
15 reviews (5 in the last 12 months)
Known for: Punctual · Fast & efficient · Honest & transparent
Canadian Roofing Company Ltd.
Free quotes · Family-run · Design service
Known for: Tidy & clean